All posts
Mentorship 4 min read 9 views
Mentors aren't cheerleaders. They're editors.
How to get feedback that actually changes your work — not just your mood.
The word 'mentor' has been drained of meaning by LinkedIn. It now covers everything from 'someone who liked my post' to 'a stranger who talked to me for 20 minutes at a conference.'
A real mentor is closer to an editor. They read your work carefully. They tell you what's not working. They don't feel the need to make you feel good about it afterward.
What good mentorship sounds like
- 'This paragraph is doing two jobs. Pick one.'
- 'You buried the point. Move it to the top.'
- 'I don't believe this claim. Where's the evidence?'
- 'This is fine. Ship it.'
What bad mentorship sounds like
- 'This is great!' (with no specifics)
- 'Just keep going, you've got this.'
- Long stories about the mentor's own career, followed by no actionable feedback.
- 'Have you thought about consulting?'
How to be a good mentee
Bring the draft, not the question. 'What should I do about my career' is unanswerable. 'Here's the two-paragraph pitch I'm sending on Tuesday, tell me what to cut' is a real ask.
The mentee who shows up with something to react to gets better mentorship than the mentee who shows up with an open agenda. Every time.